I managed to upset my mother this week by putting her on the spot in the family WhatsApp group.
Someone had talked about alcoholism as an “illness”, and it got me really triggered. When I said that labelling alcoholism as an illness wasn’t quite correct, my mother posted the World Health Organization’s definition. I couldn’t help it. Sure, listing every family member with their respective addictions to prove my point wasn’t particularly tactful, and feel free to laugh at the understatement. But I really felt strongly about it.
A coping mechanism, not a failure
I’ve long come to see addiction as a coping mechanism: something we do to adapt to a situation, to help us, rather than a sign that our body has failed. It’s not about the body or the mind being inadequate. It’s being exactly that: adapted, adequately.
If addiction stemmed from a dysfunction, we should all be sent back to the garage. Everyone has the potential to become an addict, even before we’ve encountered any trauma, which makes it much more likely. We are surrounded by sugar, caffeine, video games, social media and alcohol, all perfectly legal and omnipresent. Any of them could turn anyone into an addict in no time, without some semblance of education and self-discipline.
That’s for adults. You couldn’t possibly ask children and teenagers to exercise that kind of self-discipline, even if they knew what to do, so without their parents stepping in, many would be lost to it. The constant stimulation around us trains the brain to chase the next hit of dopamine and adrenaline. Like Gabor Maté, I see much of what we now call ADHD less as a fault in the brain and more as a sensitive nervous system responding to an overstimulating world.
The issue is less the brain’s dysfunction than our environment. And so a big part of the solution is to fix the environment, instead of trying to fix the person or the behaviour, because when we create the right conditions, we can heal faster and thrive.
Why the label doesn’t help
I’m not sure it’s helpful to tell someone with an addiction that they are ill. It implies there is something wrong with them, and it isn’t going to give them the confidence they need to solve the problem. It casts them as victims, and it can feed the very patterns we want to change.
We need to be doing the opposite. Teach them to trust their body’s innate intelligence, that there are reasons why they got to where they are, and that what they learnt to use to cope can be replaced with healthier choices. That is far more constructive and empowering.
The label often brings a judgement with it, too: that the person isn’t trying hard enough, as if it were a character flaw. That is just as untrue. Gabor Maté, the physician who spent years working with people addicted to heroin in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, asks a better question: not why the addiction, but why the pain. When you look at the stories of people living with addiction, what is required is understanding and compassion. Not a label.
In last month’s newsletter, I wrote about how words we say to ourselves can support or hinder our wellbeing. This follows the same principle. Every time we label ourselves with a pathology, we drum into ourselves that something is wrong with us.
None of this means ignoring the problem. Quite the opposite. If you or someone you love drinks heavily, medical help matters, and stopping suddenly can be dangerous, so it should be done with support. What I’m questioning is the story we tell about the person while they get that help.
Why should you care?
Because we all have times when we want to let go of behaviours that aren’t supportive of the life we want to live, or we want to learn new habits that would make us feel even more fulfilled. It could be in any area of life, not just health.
You may think “it’s hard”. You may tell yourself “I’m not capable of it”, “I’ll fail again”, “people will make fun of me”. The thing to do is the same as with a child learning to ride a bike. You’d encourage them with positive words of affirmation, to shift their focus onto building the skills they need, not on how they will fall.
Focusing on our innate knowing, on our ability to grow and to heal: that’s what solves problems. Of all kinds. No judgement, no labelling, no victimisation.
My approach is based on a deep trust in our bodies and minds to use the best tools they have, in every moment, to help us carry on living, because without them things would be much worse. For some people, the drink has been what stood between them and something far darker. Seen in that light, it did its job, until a better tool could take its place.
I don’t yet know what made my mother post that definition. I will need to have that conversation, and not in a WhatsApp group. Why it triggered me, and why my reply triggered her even more, is interesting too. I have my ideas. But those are for another day.
If you would like these newsletters as they are written, with the monthly practice and recipe that go with them, you can subscribe to Staying au Fay.